Free case review · No fee unless you winCall (325) 292-0499
San AngeloCar Accident Free Review

Injury Claims

An Old Injury, a New Crash: Making an Aggravation Claim

If you already had a bad back, a surgically repaired knee or arthritis in your neck, an insurer may say your pain has nothing to do with the crash. Texas law looks at it differently.

Updated November 17, 2026 · General information, not legal advice

Illustration of a physical therapist helping a patient stretch a shoulder
In this guide
  1. Making something worse still counts
  2. What the other side is likely to argue
  3. Building a before-and-after picture
  4. Be completely straight with your doctors
  5. Be careful with blanket records releases
  6. How it can affect the value

Plenty of people in the Concho Valley have spent years working ranch jobs, oilfield shifts or construction. By middle age, many carry an old injury: a disc that flares up now and then, a shoulder that never quite healed after a fall from a horse, a neck that stiffens in cold weather. Then a crash on Loop 306 turns a manageable ache into something that keeps you up at night.

The other driver's insurer will almost always look for that history. Here is what it means for your claim.

Making something worse still counts

Texas law generally does not let an at-fault driver off the hook just because the person they hit was not in perfect health. A crash that aggravates a prior condition can be a real, recoverable injury. The question is not "Was this person already hurt?" It is "How much worse did the crash make things, and for how long?"

Lawyers sometimes describe this as taking the injured person as you find them. A driver who hits someone with a fragile spine answers for what the collision really did to that particular body, even if a healthier person might have walked away sore for a week.

The flip side is also true: you generally cannot recover for the part of your condition that existed before and was not changed by the crash. The claim is about the difference.

What the other side is likely to argue

  • "It's degenerative." MRI reports on adults often mention disc bulges, arthritis or "degenerative changes." An insurer may say everything you feel comes from age, not the wreck.
  • "You were already treating." If you saw a chiropractor or took pain medicine before, they will say the crash changed nothing.
  • "There's a gap." Weeks without treatment after the crash can be framed as proof you were fine.
  • "You didn't tell us." If prior problems come out later and you left them off a form, your credibility takes a hit that is hard to repair.

Building a before-and-after picture

An aggravation claim is won or lost on comparison. You want a clear picture of your life the month before the crash and the months after.

Before the crash

  • How often you saw a doctor for the old problem, and when your last visit was.
  • What you could do: work full shifts, mow the yard, pick up your grandkids, drive to Abilene without stopping.
  • Any medications you took and how often.
  • Old imaging, if you had any, which gives doctors something to compare against.

After the crash

  • New symptoms, such as pain spreading down an arm or leg, numbness, or weakness you never had.
  • More frequent or more intense treatment than before.
  • New imaging that a doctor can compare with the old.
  • Work you missed or duties you had to give up. See our post on going back to work after a crash.
  • A simple journal of pain levels, sleep and the things you had to stop doing.

People who knew you before, such as a coworker, a spouse or a neighbor, can also describe the change in a way records cannot.

Be completely straight with your doctors

This is the most important part. Tell every provider about your prior injury, prior treatment and how you felt right before the crash. It can feel like you are hurting your own case. You are not. A doctor who knows the history can say, in writing, what changed and why. That opinion is far more convincing than records that pretend the old problem never existed.

Hiding history usually backfires. Insurers request prior records, and one undisclosed visit can make a jury doubt everything else you say.

Be careful with blanket records releases

The other driver's insurer may send a form asking you to authorize release of all your medical records, sometimes going back many years. Signing it can give them material unrelated to the crash to argue about. You can generally limit what you share to the relevant body parts and a reasonable time period. An attorney can handle this so the right records are shared and the rest stay private.

How it can affect the value

An aggravation claim can include medical bills for the added treatment, lost income, and pain and the loss of activities you used to manage. Texas limits recovery of medical expenses to the amounts actually paid or incurred, which our post on claim value in Texas explains. Because these cases depend on medical opinions, they often take longer than a simple soft-tissue claim.

For more about specific injuries, see car accident injuries. If an insurer is blaming your history for everything, an independent Texas injury attorney can review your situation for free. Call (325) 292-0499 or use the free case review form.

Sources

Questions people ask

Can I still file a claim if I had back problems before the accident?

Generally yes. Texas law allows recovery when a crash makes a prior condition worse. The claim covers the added harm, not the condition you already had, so records showing the change are important.

Should I tell the doctor about my old injury?

Yes. Being honest with every provider lets them explain what changed after the crash. Insurers usually find prior records anyway, and hiding them can damage your credibility.

Free · about a minute

Find out if you have a case

Answer five quick questions and an independent San Angelo-area injury attorney's office will review your crash at no cost.

Prefer to talk? Call (325) 292-0499

Free case check

5 quick questions · about a minute

What kind of crash was it?
Or call (325) 292-0499
Call nowFree case review