Free case review · No fee unless you winCall (325) 292-0499
San AngeloCar Accident Free Review

Dealing With Insurers

The Adjuster Wants a Recorded Statement. Now What?

The call often comes within a day or two of the crash, from a friendly voice asking if it is okay to record. Here is how to handle it without hurting your claim.

Updated November 17, 2026 · General information, not legal advice

Illustration of a person on a phone call while looking over insurance paperwork
In this guide
  1. Two very different calls
  2. Why they want it on tape
  3. A simple way to handle the call
  4. If you decide to give a statement
  5. Other things adjusters may ask for
  6. When your own insurer stalls
  7. Letting someone else handle the calls

After a crash, your phone starts ringing. One call is from your own insurance company. Another may be from the other driver's insurer. Both may ask to record a statement. They sound similar, but your obligations to each are very different.

Two very different calls

Your own insurer

Your auto policy is a contract, and it almost always includes a duty to cooperate. That generally means giving prompt notice of the crash and reasonable information when asked. If your insurer asks for a statement on a PIP, collision or uninsured motorist claim, refusing outright could cause problems with your coverage. You can still prepare, keep it factual and ask for a copy.

The other driver's insurer

You have no contract with them. Their adjuster's job is to evaluate the claim for their customer and their company. In general, you are not required to give the other driver's insurer a recorded statement. You can provide basic facts, such as your name, contact information, the date and place of the crash and your vehicle, without being recorded.

Why they want it on tape

A recorded statement locks in your words early, often before you have seen a doctor or read the crash report. Later, small differences between that recording and your medical records or testimony can be used to question your account.

Common questions that cause trouble:

  • "How are you feeling today?" A polite "fine" can be quoted later as proof you were not hurt.
  • "How fast were you going?" A guess can become a fact.
  • "Did you see the other car before impact?" The answer can be used to shift fault onto you.
  • "Have you ever hurt your back before?" A broad history question can open old records.

Texas uses modified comparative fault, so anything that moves even part of the blame to you can reduce what you recover. Read Texas car accident laws for the basics.

A simple way to handle the call

You can be polite and still protect yourself. Something like this works:

"I can confirm my name, contact information and the date and location of the crash. I am not giving a recorded statement right now. Please send any requests in writing."

Then keep notes: the adjuster's name, company, phone number, claim number, and the date and time of the call.

If the adjuster pushes back, you do not have to argue. Repeat that you will respond to written questions and end the call. Adjusters handle many claims and are used to hearing this. Declining a recording is not rude, and it is not an admission of anything. It simply gives you time to see a doctor, get the crash report and think before your words are saved.

If you decide to give a statement

Sometimes a statement makes sense, especially to your own insurer. If you give one:

  • Prepare first. Review your notes, photos and the crash report.
  • Answer only the question asked. Keep your answers short and true.
  • Do not guess. "I do not know" and "I am not sure" are fine answers.
  • Do not downplay injuries. Describe what you feel and mention that you are still being evaluated if that is true.
  • Do not speculate about fault. Describe what happened, not who was to blame.
  • Ask for a copy of the recording or transcript.

Other things adjusters may ask for

Medical authorizations

A broad authorization can give an insurer access to years of unrelated records. You can generally limit what you share to records related to the crash, and you can send records yourself.

Quick settlement offers

An early check can be tempting, especially with bills piling up. A settlement usually requires signing a release that ends the claim. Read our post on the settlement timeline before signing anything.

Social media and photos

Assume what you post may be seen. Keep posts about the crash and your activities offline until the claim is resolved.

When your own insurer stalls

Your insurer has duties to you too. Texas law sets deadlines for insurers to handle first-party claims, and the Texas Department of Insurance takes consumer complaints. If your PIP or collision claim is stuck, ask in writing what is missing. Our insurance claims guide walks through the steps, and Texas PIP explained covers your own no-fault coverage.

Letting someone else handle the calls

Once you have an attorney, adjusters generally must communicate through that attorney. Many people find that a relief. For a free review with an independent Texas injury attorney, call (325) 292-0499.

Sources

Questions people ask

Do I have to give a recorded statement to the other driver's insurance?

Generally no. You have no contract with the other driver's insurer. You can share basic facts without agreeing to be recorded.

Do I have to cooperate with my own insurance company?

Your policy almost always requires reasonable cooperation, which may include a statement. You can still prepare, stick to facts and ask for a copy.

Can I take back something I said in a recorded statement?

You can correct a mistake, preferably in writing, but the original recording usually still exists. That is why preparing before any statement matters.

Free · about a minute

Find out if you have a case

Answer five quick questions and an independent San Angelo-area injury attorney's office will review your crash at no cost.

Prefer to talk? Call (325) 292-0499

Free case check

5 quick questions · about a minute

What kind of crash was it?
Or call (325) 292-0499
Call nowFree case review